When disaster strikes, satellites can provide information that would be nearly impossible to obtain from the ground. They can reveal the extent of flooding, identify damaged infrastructure, track wildfires and help emergency responders determine where assistance is needed most. Much of that information is already shared through established international arrangements, often without charge to those responding to the disaster.
The International Charter: Space and Major Disasters is perhaps the clearest example. Established in 2000, the Charter brings together space agencies and satellite operators to provide Earth observation data and analyzed information products during major disasters. Commercial providers contribute imagery alongside government operators, and affected countries can request assistance regardless of whether they are Charter members.
This is an important achievement. It demonstrates that humanitarian cooperation and commercial remote sensing are not inherently incompatible. The industry has already developed mechanisms through which valuable satellite information can be made available without requiring disaster-stricken governments to purchase it.
But the existence of a successful voluntary system does not resolve every legal and ethical question. What happens when a disaster falls outside established arrangements? Who pays for specialized analysis that goes beyond the assistance already available? How should national security restrictions be handled? And what responsibility do States and commercial operators have to ensure that countries receiving satellite information can actually use it?
The challenge is not simply persuading satellite operators to share their data. It is determining how far existing humanitarian commitments should extend and how to ensure that access to information translates into effective disaster response.
A Moral Obligation Is Not Necessarily a Legal One
Consider a country facing a devastating natural disaster. Satellite imagery could help identify isolated communities, determine which roads remain passable and direct emergency responders to areas where lives are at risk. If that information exists, should access depend on the affected country’s ability to pay?
There is a compelling moral argument that it should not. This is particularly important for developing States, including Pacific Island nations facing significant environmental threats. Countries with limited financial and technological resources may be among those most dependent on satellite information to anticipate disasters, assess damage and coordinate emergency responses.
Yet humanitarian need does not automatically create an unlimited legal obligation for a private company to subsidize disaster response. Satellites are expensive to build, launch and operate. Commercial operators must recover those investments to remain viable and continue developing technologies that may ultimately benefit everyone. The existence of voluntary humanitarian arrangements demonstrates a willingness to cooperate, but it does not eliminate the financial realities of operating a commercial satellite system.
The United Nations Principles Relating to Remote Sensing of the Earth from Outer Space, adopted in 1986, recognize the humanitarian value of satellite data. Principle XI calls for relevant data and information to be transmitted as promptly as possible to States affected or likely to be affected by natural disasters. However, the Principles were adopted through a General Assembly resolution, not a binding treaty. They express important international expectations without, by themselves, establishing a general enforceable obligation requiring every commercial operator to provide free disaster-related imagery.
The Charter demonstrates how these expectations can be translated into practical cooperation. Rather than relying on a universal legal mandate, participating organizations contribute resources through an established voluntary framework. The arrangement has proved valuable, but it also raises a broader question: should humanitarian access to satellite information depend primarily on voluntary participation, or should international law establish more specific responsibilities?
The Data May Be Free. Making It Useful Is Not.
Providing access to satellite imagery is only one part of effective disaster response. An image may show a flooded region, but emergency responders need to know which roads remain passable, where infrastructure has failed and which communities are most urgently in need of assistance. Turning satellite observations into actionable information requires processing, expertise, infrastructure and time.
The Charter recognizes this challenge and provides more than raw imagery. Its activations can produce maps and other analyzed information products designed to support emergency response. This is an important distinction because the humanitarian value of remote sensing depends not simply on collecting information but on making it usable.
Nevertheless, the availability of analyzed products through the Charter does not mean that every information need can be met. Some emergencies may require specialized analysis, additional satellite acquisitions, continuous monitoring or products tailored to the particular circumstances of the affected State. Such services may exceed the resources available through existing humanitarian arrangements.
Commercial operators also have legitimate financial interests. Their employees, equipment, ground infrastructure and analytical capabilities all require investment. Expecting companies to provide unlimited services without compensation could undermine the very capabilities on which humanitarian organizations increasingly rely.
One possible approach is for governments or international organizations to cover the costs of additional analysis when humanitarian needs exceed the assistance available through established mechanisms. Another would be an international funding arrangement supported by contributions from States according to their economic capacity. Such a system could help compensate commercial operators while ensuring that countries with limited resources are not excluded from essential services.
Of course, these proposals introduce their own challenges. Who would determine which requests qualify for financial support? How would the costs be distributed? Would States contribute consistently to a system that might primarily benefit countries other than their own? And how could additional funding mechanisms complement existing arrangements without creating unnecessary bureaucracy or duplication?
When Does the Emergency End?
Another difficult question concerns the distinction between immediate humanitarian assistance and longer-term recovery. There is a strong argument for prioritizing access when human lives are in immediate danger. Imagery that could help locate survivors, direct evacuations or identify safe routes may justify extraordinary measures.
But satellite data remains valuable long after the initial emergency. Reconstruction, infrastructure planning, insurance assessments and long-term environmental monitoring all depend on reliable information. These activities may extend well beyond the immediate disaster-response phase and increasingly overlap with ordinary commercial markets for Earth observation services.
A possible approach is to distinguish between emergency response and longer-term recovery, with free or subsidized access during the former and ordinary commercial arrangements resuming during the latter. This would recognize the urgency of saving lives while preserving the commercial value of satellite products and services.
Even that distinction is difficult to apply. Disasters do not follow neat timelines, and the consequences of a major flood, wildfire or earthquake may threaten human life long after the initial event. A community without functioning roads, clean water or reliable infrastructure may remain in danger for weeks or months. Determining when humanitarian assistance should end requires more than simply declaring the immediate emergency over.
The challenge is developing arrangements that recognize the continuing needs of affected populations without transforming every post-disaster commercial service into an indefinite obligation to provide free information.
The Risks of Getting It Wrong
Providing satellite information also creates risks when that information is inaccurate, outdated or misunderstood. Remote sensing does not always provide a complete picture, and interpreting satellite data may involve considerable uncertainty.
A government that relies on incorrect information could direct emergency responders to unsafe locations, fail to evacuate communities facing imminent danger or allocate scarce resources to areas where they are not needed. The consequences could be particularly serious for States that lack the technical capacity to independently evaluate the information they receive.
This raises questions about liability and accountability. Could a commercial operator face legal claims if it voluntarily provides disaster-related information that later proves inaccurate? Would the answer change if the company charged for its analysis? Should providers be protected by contractual limitations of liability or agreed standards governing the quality and use of humanitarian data?
These concerns also support a broader argument for capacity building. Rather than relying indefinitely on foreign governments and commercial providers, developing States should have greater opportunities to build their own capabilities to interpret satellite data and integrate it into disaster planning.
Access to information is valuable, but access without the ability to understand and act on that information may accomplish very little. Long-term investment in local technical expertise could reduce dependence on foreign providers while allowing States to establish their own priorities for disaster preparedness and response.
Of course, capacity building takes time, and disasters do not wait for institutions to develop. Strengthening national capabilities should complement, rather than replace, immediate international assistance.
National Security Complicates the Equation
Satellite imagery that could assist humanitarian responders might also reveal military installations, troop movements or sensitive infrastructure. Releasing information during an armed conflict may create risks beyond the immediate disaster.
The tension is particularly difficult because national security concerns are themselves connected to the protection of human life. Information that helps emergency responders reach vulnerable communities could also assist military actors in identifying targets or planning operations. A decision intended to save lives in one context could place others at risk.
This is where shutter control, the ability of governments to restrict certain commercial remote sensing operations or the dissemination of imagery for national security reasons, enters the discussion. Restrictions may be justified when releasing information creates a specific and identifiable security threat. But withholding all imagery from an affected region may unnecessarily interfere with humanitarian assistance.
A more tailored approach might include withholding sensitive portions of imagery, limiting resolution or delaying release rather than denying access altogether. Such measures would not eliminate every risk, but they could provide emergency responders with essential information while protecting legitimate security interests.
The challenge is determining who should make those decisions. Commercial satellite operators possess considerable technical expertise, but they may lack the information necessary to evaluate the national security implications of releasing particular images. Governments may be better positioned to assess those risks, although their decisions may also reflect political considerations extending beyond immediate security concerns.
Humanitarian assistance and national security need not always be competing objectives. Carefully designed procedures may accommodate both, but doing so requires clear standards and cooperation between governments, commercial operators and humanitarian organizations.
Beyond Free Data
The International Charter: Space and Major Disasters demonstrates that the international community has already made significant progress in providing satellite information for humanitarian purposes. Through voluntary cooperation, government and commercial operators contribute valuable resources to disaster response. The question is not whether this model works, but how its achievements can be strengthened and extended.
Government compensation for additional commercial services, international cost-sharing arrangements, clearer standards for data quality, safeguards against liability and investment in the technical capabilities of developing States all offer possible approaches. None is without complications, but each recognizes that humanitarian access and commercial sustainability need not be mutually exclusive.
The discussion also raises a broader question about the relationship between law and voluntary cooperation. The 1986 Remote Sensing Principles express an expectation that satellite information should contribute to disaster protection. The Charter demonstrates how that expectation can be implemented through practical arrangements without the need for a binding international treaty.
Yet voluntary cooperation has limits. It depends on continued participation, available resources and the willingness of organizations to contribute. As commercial remote sensing becomes increasingly important to disaster preparedness and response, there may be a growing need to clarify responsibilities, strengthen coordination and ensure that existing arrangements remain capable of meeting expanding demands.
Ultimately, the challenge is not simply whether a company should provide an image for free. It is who should bear the cost of turning satellite data into life-saving information, who decides when humanitarian need is sufficiently urgent and how to ensure that countries most vulnerable to disasters are not also those least able to benefit from the technology that could protect them.
Remote sensing has given humanity extraordinary capabilities to observe disasters as they unfold. The International Charter has shown that those capabilities can be mobilized through international cooperation. The next challenge is ensuring that the benefits of that cooperation extend beyond access to imagery and translate into lasting improvements in disaster preparedness, response and resilience.
The ability to see a disaster from space is remarkable. Ensuring that the information reaches those who can use it to save lives is the responsibility we must continue to address.
Kathleen Brett, Ashley Burroughs, Joseph Clark, Kellie Jenkins, Austin Kwikkel, Hugh Londrey, Ashley Miller, Peyton Reed, Craig Scheer, Michael Stiller, Manzurakhon Talipova


Leave a Reply